The Best Cheeses to Use in a Turkey Sandwich

Chances are you’re a tax-paying, lawn-mowing, shower-taking adult. You have your life together, and you’ve heard that some people put meat and cheese between two pieces of bread.

When I was a lifeguard years ago, most of the other people there were pretty young and didn’t have their lives totally together. We were tax-paying for sure, but mowing lawns and taking showers were few and far between.

People would go “ooh” and “ahh” over these sandwiches every time I brought them to work on my break. Maybe you’re in the same kind of season in your life and could use some sandwich suggestions. Well I’m here to help!.

A turkey sandwich is a classic lunch or snack. But plain turkey between bread can be a bit boring. Adding cheese takes your turkey sandwich up a level, adding flavor, texture and creaminess. With so many cheeses to choose from, which ones pair best with turkey?

Here are the top cheeses to elevate your turkey sandwich

Swiss Cheese

With its distinctive holes and nutty, slightly sweet flavor, Swiss cheese is a great choice for turkey sandwiches. Its firm yet sliceable texture stands up well when layered with turkey and other fillings. The mild flavor of Swiss doesn’t overpower the turkey.

Try pairing Swiss cheese with lettuce, tomato and turkey on whole wheat bread. A spread of mustard or mayo finishes it off.

Provolone

Provolone is an Italian cheese that comes in smooth-textured slices perfect for sandwiches. It has a mild milky flavor that blends well with turkey.

You can keep it simple by just pairing provolone with sliced turkey breast and crisp lettuce on sourdough. Or make it more flavorful with the addition of roasted red peppers, pesto mayo and arugula.

Cheddar Cheese

For those who like more robust cheese flavors, sharp cheddar is a delicious choice for a turkey sandwich Its salty, tangy taste contrasts nicely with the mild turkey.

Try cheddar with thinly sliced apple, lettuce and turkey on cranberry walnut bread for a gourmet sandwich with sweet and savory flavors.

Havarti

Creamy havarti from Denmark is buttery and smooth in texture. It has a mildly acidic flavor that melds beautifully with turkey.

Make your sandwich delicious by pairing havarti cheese with turkey, sliced pear, crisp romaine lettuce and honey mustard on a crusty French baguette.

Gouda

Gouda originating from the Netherlands has a distinctive sweet, nutty taste. Its creamy texture and mild flavor complement turkey perfectly without being overpowering.

For a simple but scrumptious sandwich, layer gouda cheese, lettuce, tomato and turkey between two slices of whole grain bread spread with mayo or mustard.

Monterey Jack

If you prefer melted cheese on a hot turkey sandwich or panini, Monterey Jack is the perfect choice. It has a mild flavor and melts smoothly when grilled or toasted.

Try Monterey Jack cheese with avocado, tomato and turkey on crusty artisan bread for a hot, flavor-packed sandwich.

So experiment with different cheeses like Swiss, cheddar, provolone and havarti to take your turkey sandwich up a notch! The right cheese provides creaminess, flavor and the perfect complement to the turkey.

what kind of cheese goes on a turkey sandwich

The best turkey sandwich

I believe quality of ingredients is what really makes a sandwich. I use a whole wheat hoagie roll for this because it keeps its shape well and can handle having a lot of ingredients stacked on top of it. Regular sandwich bread could be used, but I can’t promise that the right amounts would be used or that the bread wouldn’t get soggy from the filling.

I also used deli turkey off the bone, but a smoked turkey breast would also be great. You can toast this turkey sandwich in the oven for a few minutes or in a panini press, and it tastes great either way.

what kind of cheese goes on a turkey sandwich

Do you put mayo on a turkey sandwich?

Of course, this is a sandwich, so everything I use is optional. I actually don’t eat mayonnaise, so I always leave that off, but can appreciate its value for others.

Fast and Easy Turkey Sandwich for Lunch | Recipe by Lounging with Lenny

FAQ

What kind of cheese is good with turkey sandwiches?

Cheese — The best cheese for turkey sandwiches are provolone, gouda, mozzarella, Colby jack, Monterey jack, and cheddar are all great options. You don’t want the cheese to overpower the other ingredients. It also needs to melt easily if you’re grilling it.

What cheese turkey pairing?

A turkey sandwich could use provolone, or havarti, or Muenster, or Swiss or American, or gouda —aka, any mild cheese, if you don’t want the cheese to be intrusive. Or you could use stilton or bleu or chèvre, or any pungent cheese to make you take notice of it.

What cheese goes well with a turkey sandwich?

Here are 9 of the best cheeses for turkey sandwiches, along with some pairing suggestions: 1. Gouda: This Dutch cheese has a mild, sweet, and creamy flavor with a hint of butterscotch. Its semi-firm texture makes it perfect for both cold and grilled turkey sandwiches. Pair it with arugula, apple, and smoked turkey on sourdough bread. 2.

What is the healthy substitute of cottage cheese?

Cottage cheese itself is a healthy option to include in daily diet as it is made of milk and rich in protein and calcium. If one has to substitute cottage cheese for various reasons then tofu is one such option which can be used and has good protein content too. Or mozzarella cheese or other types of low fat cheese options can be used to certain extent as a substitute.

Should you add cheese to a turkey sandwich?

Adding cheese to a turkey sandwich is a simple way to enhance its flavor and texture The right cheese can: Add a new dimension of flavor: Cheese can add a richness, tanginess, or nuttiness that complements the delicate taste of turkey. Enhance the texture: Some cheeses melt beautifully, creating a gooey, satisfying experience.

What cheese goes well with roasted turkey breast?

However, it can provide you with smokey and nutty undertones that go very well in combination with roasted turkey breast. Provolone is the perfect type of cheese for cold turkey sandwiches that incorporate ingredients like whole grain bread, pesto mayonnaise, and baby spinach leaves.

Is Swiss cheese good for turkey sandwiches?

Swiss When it comes to turkey sandwiches, Swiss is the perfect cheese for adding both flavor and texture. Swiss cheese has a delicate yet nutty taste that complements the turkey nicely without overpowering it. Plus, with its firm texture and eye-catching holes all over, it adds an interesting visual presentation.

What cheese goes well with smoked turkey?

Cheddar: This English cheese has a strong, sharp flavor with an earthy, pungent taste. It’s a bold choice for turkey sandwiches but pairs well with smoked turkey and adds a delicious complexity. Enjoy it with thinly sliced red onion, cherry tomatoes, and a drizzle of balsamic vinegar. 6.

Leave a Comment