As Thanksgiving approaches, home cooks start planning for the star of the holiday meal – the turkey! With multiple oven settings to choose from, a common question arises – should you bake or roast the turkey? Understanding the difference between these two cooking methods is key to ensuring perfect, juicy results
What’s the Difference Between Baking and Roasting?
The terms baking and roasting are sometimes used interchangeably, but they actually refer to different oven cooking techniques:
-
Baking relies on heat from the bottom oven element. It’s great for foods that need a crisp bottom like cookies, pizza, casseroles
-
Roasting uses both top and bottom heat elements to surround food in steady, even heat. This method is ideal for cooking meats like turkey, chicken, and roasts.
For turkey specifically, roasting is definitely the better choice. The heat from above and below cooks the bird evenly from all sides, keeping the interior moist while crisping up the skin.
Baking risks uneven cooking since the heat only comes from the bottom element. This can lead to overcooked breast meat and undercooked thighs.
Should You Use a Convection Oven?
Many modern ovens come with a convection setting. This uses a fan to circulate hot air around the oven cavity, allowing for faster, more even cooking.
Cooking turkey in a convection oven can reduce roasting time by about 25% versus a standard oven. The constant airflow ensures the turkey browns and cooks evenly with crispy skin and moist meat all the way through.
If using convection, simply lower the temperature by 25°F compared to the standard roast setting to prevent over-browning. Monitor internal temperatures closely and tent with foil if needed.
Tips for Perfect Roast Turkey
Follow these handy tips for roasting turkey success:
-
Start with a fully thawed turkey – don’t roast frozen.
-
Use a roasting pan with a rack to elevate the bird. This allows air circulation for even cooking.
-
Pat the turkey dry and rub all over with olive oil or butter to help achieve crispy skin.
-
Roast breast side up on the lower oven rack, centered for optimal heat circulation.
-
Cook stuffing separately to ensure it reaches a safe internal temperature.
-
Baste with pan drippings every 30 minutes to add moisture and flavor.
-
Tent with foil if browning too quickly. Cover the breast, wings, and drumsticks as needed.
-
Let
What temperature setting should I use when preparing a whole bird/holiday meal?
The preferred method is to roast the turkey in the center of the lowest rack or oven shelf so the top of the turkey will be centered in the oven. If two racks must be used, place the turkey on the lowest or middle rack. When cooking with two roasting pans, position the pans in opposite corners of the oven. Place the pans so one is not directly over the other.
How long do I cook a turkey in a convection oven?
Depending on the size of your turkey, follow the chart for convection cooking or until you’ve reached the proper temperature. Use a meat thermometer to test the temperature in the thickest part of the thigh but not touching the bone. If your turkey is stuffed, also verify the temperature of the stuffing has reached 165°F.
- 12-15 pounds, 1.5-2 hours
- 15-20 pounds, 2-2.5 hours
- 20-25 pounds, 2.5-3 hours
Other signs that the turkey is done are that the legs move loosely, and the juices run clear. Verify the internal temperature in several places – the thickest parts of the breast, thigh and wing – to be sure.
Depending on your brand of oven, it is recommended to reduce traditional turkey baking times from 10-40 percent.
A Beginner’s Guide to Roasting a Turkey | Food Wishes
FAQ
Should I use bake or roast setting for turkey?
Should I roast or bake a turkey? A combination of baking and roasting may be the ideal method for a juicy turkey with golden brown, crispy skin. One method is to start with an oven heated to 450°F and then immediately reduce the temperature to 350°F (or 325°F for a large bird).
What is the difference between roasting and baking a turkey?
Roasting uses more direct heat from the top element and usually a higher temperature >400F. Typically you are cooking meat or browning vegetables, uncovered on a sheet. You wouldn’t roast a pie or loaf of bread. Baking uses indirect heat from the bottom and typically a gentler temperature.
What cooking method is best for turkey?
Indirect heat is ideal for cooking whole turkeys, which need slower cooking.
Is turkey better in a roaster or oven?
Roasting it in the oven first might give you the color, but the slow moist cooking of a roaster oven will soften the skin to a less than pleasant texture. Your best bet is to cook the turkey in the roaster oven first, THEN roast it in a high heat in the oven to brown it up and crisp up the skin.