After hours of careful preparation, seasoning, monitoring, adjusting, and resting, you’ve got the turkey beautifully golden-browned and you’re already basking in well-earned ooohs from the family.
But when you start to carve the breast, you notice that some of the meat has a pinkish hue. What’s the story? Is it undercooked? Is dinner doomed?
The short answer: As long as the interior was cooked to a safe temperature, pink color in meat is perfectly fine, and you can let the feast proceed.
As Thanksgiving approaches, many home cooks are busy preparing their holiday turkeys. After spending hours roasting and basting your turkey to perfection the last thing you want to see when carving it is pink meat. The sight of pink turkey can be alarming causing many cooks to wonder – is pink turkey bad?
I decided to dig into the science and facts behind pink poultry to find out if it’s safe to eat. After researching expert opinions and food safety guidelines, I’m happy to report that pink turkey is perfectly fine to eat as long as it reaches the proper internal temperature.
Here’s a comprehensive guide examining why turkey turns pink, how to tell if it’s safe, and what to do if you end up with a pretty in pink bird on your table.
Why Does Turkey Turn Pink?
Before determining if pink turkey is bad, it helps to understand why properly cooked poultry sometimes takes on a rosy hue.
According to poultry scientists, two naturally occurring pigments are responsible for the color of turkey meat – myoglobin and hemoglobin. Myoglobin lends a rich red color while hemoglobin contains shades of pink and violet.
Typically, exposure to heat denatures and breaks down these pigments, turning the meat from red/pink to tan or brown. However, elements like marinades and rubs can prevent the pigments from fully breaking down sometimes.
The sodium and moisture from marinades helps turkey retain its natural pigments instead of denaturing them. This moisture retention leads to meat that appears undercooked and pink when in reality, it’s just the pigments being preserved that create the color.
In addition, young birds with more porous bones see pinkness around joints more often. Why? Hemoglobin can leak from the bone into nearby meat, tinging it pink.
Is Pink Turkey Safe to Eat?
Now that we know why pink turkey happens, the real question is – can you safely eat it?
According to food safety experts, pink meat is 100% safe as long as the turkey reaches an internal temperature of 165°F.
“As long as the internal temperature hits 165°F, the turkey is safe to eat even if it looks pink,” says food safety specialist Jonathan Howland.
The USDA confirms that appearance alone cannot determine whether poultry is properly cooked or not. Only a food thermometer can accurately check doneness.
As long as the turkey exceeds 165°F internally, it is safe to consume regardless of color. The pink hue is simply an aesthetic issue rather than a food safety one.
Proper Internal Cooking Temperatures for Turkey
To ensure turkey doesn’t harbor any harmful bacteria, it must reach a safe minimum internal temperature of 165°F. Poultry held at 165°F for at least 15 seconds is hot enough to kill potential pathogens.
Here are the proper internal temperatures according to USDA guidelines:
- Whole turkey: 165°F
- Turkey breast: 165°F
- Turkey thighs/legs: 165°F
- Stuffing: 165°F
- Leftovers/casseroles: 165°F
What Causes Undercooked Turkey?
While pink turkey isn’t dangerous, actual undercooking can lead to foodborne illness. Here are some common missteps that result in underdone birds:
- Not fully thawing frozen turkey
- Cooking at too low of temperature
- Not roasting for long enough
- Failing to use a meat thermometer
- Not allowing the turkey to rest before carving
- Improper thermometer use/placement
As long as you properly thaw, cook, temp, and rest the turkey, it will reach the safe internal temperature of 165°F regardless of color.
Should You Avoid Eating Pink Turkey?
Since pink turkey is safe scientifically, there is no need to avoid eating it from a food safety perspective. However, if the unappetizing color bothers you, there are some tips for reducing pink poultry:
- Brine turkey before roasting
- Avoid marinades/rubs with salt or sugar
- Cook turkey low and slow
- Roast to 170°F for extra safety margin
- Let turkey rest 30+ minutes before carving
- Slice carefully to avoid smearing surface pigments
But keep in mind that following these guidelines can’t guarantee a perfectly brown bird. Traces of pink may persist thanks to the natural pigments in the meat.
The Bottom Line
While many associate pink meat with undercooking, turkey can retain a rosy hue even when cooked to a safe internal temperature of 165°F. As long as you properly use a food thermometer to check for doneness, pink turkey is perfectly safe to eat. The color is simply an aesthetic issue, not a food safety one.
So this Thanksgiving, embrace the pink! As long as your turkey reaches 165°F internally, you can safely serve it with total peace of mind. The only real turkey-related concern should be saving room for second helpings!
What Makes Raw Poultry Pink?
Animal muscle naturally contains a few different red-pink pigments.
Myoglobin, a protein that carries oxygen within muscle tissue, is the pigment that’s predominantly responsible for the pink color of raw meat. Myoglobin is heat-sensitive, and it is mostly denatured during cooking, losing much of its color. That’s why we commonly associate pink meat with raw meat.
A more stable pink pigment in muscle is called cytochrome c. Turkeys have more of this pigment than chickens do, and older birds have more of it than younger ones.
Sign up for the Cook’s Insider newsletter
The latest recipes, tips, and tricks, plus behind-the-scenes stories from the Cooks Illustrated team.Email addressAmericas Test Kitchen will not sell, rent, or disclose your email address to third parties unless otherwise notified. Your email address is required to identify you for free access to content on the site. You will also receive free newsletters and notification of Americas Test Kitchen specials.
Pink Turkey Meat 101
FAQ
Is pink turkey safe to eat?
Yes, a little pink is fine (happens with turkey and chicken both)–you’ll just want to make sure that the thigh meat looks firm and cooked, not soft or raw still.
Is turkey ok if it’s a little pink reddit?
Pink juices does not mean unsafe. What you are interested in is pasteurization time at a held temp. There is a good article by Kenji Lopez-Alt on serious eats about it. “According to the USDA’s own data, as long as your turkey spends at least 3.7 minutes at or above 150°F (66°C), it is safe to eat.”
How can you tell if a turkey is undercooked?
Texture: Properly cooked meat should be firm to the touch but not overly tough. Undercooked meat will feel soft and mushy.Oct 15, 2024
Why is my cooked turkey pink in the fridge?
Baker says nitrates may also be causing the pink hue. “Nitrates are commonly used in cured meats and give a pink color,” she says. “There are naturally occurring nitrates and nitrites in the meat that may also be contributing, despite being completely cooked.”
Is pink Turkey safe to eat?
Only by using a food thermometer can one accurately determine that poultry has reached a safe minimum internal temperature of 165 °F throughout the product. Turkey can remain pink even after cooking to a safe minimum internal temperature of 165 °F. The meat of smoked turkey is always pink.
Can you eat a Turkey with a pink tinge?
As long as the turkey has reached the safe minimum internal temperature, it should be safe to eat even if portions have a pink tinge. To confirm your turkey is thoroughly cooked a food thermometer is essential. Color is not a reliable indicator but temperature is. Here are some tips
Does smoked turkey have a pink tinge?
Turkey can remain pink even after cooking to a safe minimum internal temperature of 165 °F. The meat of smoked turkey is always pink. Does my Turkey have a pink tinge?
What happens if you eat a pink Turkey?
At high temperatures, it loses its ability to bind oxygen and turns pink. Over time, the pigment does regain its ability to bind oxygen, and the pink tinge fades. That is why the leftover meat in the refrigerator rarely seems to have this unseemly blush the next day. Is it safe to eat a pink Turkey?
Why does turkey meat turn pink when cooked?
So while the outer turkey meat changes from pink to white during cooking, the myoglobin near the bones is somewhat shielded from the heat. This causes the innermost meat to retain a pinkish or red tint. Is Pink Turkey Meat Safe? How To Tell If Turkey Is Done As stated earlier, color alone does not indicate whether turkey is safe to eat.
How do you know if a cooked turkey is pink?
Only by using a food thermometer can one accurately determine that poultry has reached a safe minimum internal temperature of 165 °F throughout the product. Turkey can remain pink even after cooking to a safe minimum internal temperature of 165 °F. Why is my cooked turkey pink after being in the fridge?