Mastering Smoked Turkey Breast on a Pit Boss Pellet Grill

Once you own a pellet grill you look forward to smoking meat year-round and showing off all that juicy and delicious meat candy to all your family and friends–but during the holiday season, the stakes couldnt be higher.

With everyone counting on you to create a perfectly seasoned and smoked turkey, anxiety can set in (especially for first-timers) and so we created this guide to walk you through it step by step, and answer any lingering questions about the turkey smoking process.

Here is a handy Table Of Contents we created so you can jump around to the different steps in the process…

A juicy smoked turkey breast makes for a stellar centerpiece any time of year. While smoking a whole turkey is a major endeavor, focusing on just the breast portions keeps it fast and easy. With the right technique, you can churn out amazing smoked turkey breasts on your Pit Boss pellet grill.

As avid Pit Boss owners, we’ve smoked our share of turkey breasts Follow our guide to go from dry disappointment to perfect, mouthwatering smoked turkey breast off your Pit Boss every time.

Why Smoke a Turkey Breast?

Going with breast over a whole bird has some excellent advantages:

  • Smaller size: A bone-in breast runs 4-8 pounds, much more manageable.

  • Shorter cook time You can smoke a breast in only 2-4 hours versus 4-6 for a whole turkey.

  • More smoke flavor: With far more surface area exposed, the breast gets maximum smoke absorption.

  • Less waste No need to discard excess parts like wings, backbone etc.

  • Anytime option: Enjoy smoky turkey well past the holidays.

Picking the Right Turkey Breast

A few tips for choosing the best breast for smoking:

  • Bone-in over boneless: Bone-in retains way more moisture and prevents drying out.

  • No injections/brines: Look for all natural with no added solutions so flavors don’t compete with smoke.

  • 1/2 to 1 pound per person: Figure a 4-8 pound breast for 6-10 people.

  • Thaw ahead: Give frozen breast 2-3 days thawing in the fridge before smoking day.

Should You Brine?

While not mandatory, brining does make the breast extra juicy and seasoned. Make a simple brine with:

  • 2 quarts water
  • 1/4 cup salt
  • 1/4 cup brown sugar
  • Spices like garlic, peppercorns, bay leaves (optional)

Submerge the breast 12-24 hours, rinse, and pat dry before smoking.

Setting Up the Pit Boss

Proper setup is key for smoking success:

  • Use milder pellets like apple, maple, cherry, or pecan.

  • Set temperature between 225-250°F for low, slow smoking.

  • Place breast directly on grill grates, away from direct heat.

  • Insert food probes into thickest section to monitor temp.

Preparing and Seasoning

Keep the preparations simple:

  • Coat with olive oil so seasoning adheres.

  • For rubs, opt for basic salt & pepper, herbs, or lemon pepper.

  • Apply seasoning right before smoking so it stays vibrant.

  • If desired, inject breast with low-sodium chicken broth for added moisture.

Maintaining Ideal Smoking Temps

The key to great smoke flavor is keeping the Pit Boss at a steady, low temp:

  • Avoid big temperature swings – keep it between 225-250°F.

  • Monitor pellet level and add more before running out.

  • Use a smoke tube if you want more smoke.

  • Spritz the breast with apple juice or cider every 45-60 minutes.

Monitoring Doneness

With a bone-in breast, target an internal temp of 160-165°F. Monitor it closely:

  • Insert food probe in thickest part, away from bone.

  • Test center in multiple spots on larger breasts.

  • When done, it should hit 165°F and juices run clear.

Allowing Proper Rest Time

Letting the breast rest is crucial for moisture:

  • Allow to rest 20-30 minutes before slicing.

  • Loosely tent with foil to keep warm.

  • The internal temp will rise 5-10 degrees during resting.

Serving Up Your Smoked Masterpiece

A smoked turkey breast makes for amazing meals:

  • Slice thinly for sandwiches, salads, and appetizer trays.

  • Dice it up for pasta dishes, soup, casseroles, and snacks.

  • Pair it with your favorite sides as a stunning entrée.

With the right prep and smoking methods, your Pit Boss pellet grill can turn out foolproof, juicy smoked turkey breast the whole gang will rave about.

Smoked Turkey Breast Pit Boss Tips

Here are some additional tips for smoking turkey breast perfection on your Pit Boss:

  • Try cooking breast side down initially for maximum juiciness. Flip over later to crisp the skin.

  • Use a disposable foil pan under the breast to catch drippings for gravy.

  • If breast is very large, cook at a lower temp like 180°F for first few hours.

  • Wrap breast in foil if the skin starts getting too dark before the interior is done.

  • Try different wood pellet flavors like hickory, apple, cherry, etc to alter the smoke profile.

  • Inject with creole butter and use a blackening seasoning for a Cajun turkey breast.

  • Glaze with maple syrup, honey, or bbq sauce the last 30 minutes for added flavor.

Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

It’s easy to mess up smoked turkey breast if you’re not careful:

Problem: Turkey breast turns out overly dry.

Solution: Brine first and don’t overcook. Remove from grill at 160-165°F.

Problem: Skin is leathery or rubbery.

Solution: Use higher heat (325+°F) at the very end to crisp the skin.

Problem: Breast is underdone or raw inside.

Solution: Cook to proper internal temp of 165°F. Check in multiple areas.

Problem: Meat lacks much smoke flavor.

Solution: Use more wood pellets, add a smoke tube, cook at lower temp.

Problem: Breast has an off or strong bitter flavor.

Solution: Avoid temperature spikes. Discard bitter pellets.

Mastering the Details = Pit Boss Smoked Turkey Breast Perfection

It’s the mastery of the small details that takes your smoked turkey breast to the next level:

  • Nailing the prep like brining, seasoning, and temperature setting

  • Maintaining an ideal, steady smoking temp

  • Knowing exactly when it’s done via internal temp

  • Letting it rest sufficiently to lock in moisture

Get these details dialed in on your Pit Boss pellet grill and you’ll be rewarded with insane smoked turkey breast everyone will rave about.

The next time a turkey breast sounds good, skip the whole bird. Fire up your Pit Boss instead for a crowd-pleasing smoked turkey breast that’s juicy, tender and bursting with flavor.

how to smoke turkey breast on a pit boss

How To Prep The Turkey For The Pellet Grill

Long before we start burning pellets we need to prep our bird, so lets talk options.

What woods are best with smoked turkey?

I recommend any fruitwoods such as apple, cherry, and peach. You can also use mild competition blends, usually a blend of pecan, hickory, and oak.

Smoke flavor is subjective but I personally would stay away from really robust woods like mesquite and post oak for smoking turkey, though many people would disagree with me, especially in South Texas.

The best wood for smoked turkey is a mild wood with a smoke aroma that the whole family likes.

how to smoke turkey breast on a pit boss

Now were ready to smoke. Heat the smoker to 250 degrees f and prepare a water pan (a small pan of water…I use an old bread pan or an aluminum pan) full of water and place it in the chamber.

The water pan adds moisture to the chamber and helps the smoke penetrate and adhere to the turkey. Though pellet grills dont usually need help maintaining a consistent temperature like stick smokers do, the water pan still provides moisture in the air.

Bring the large turkey out to the pellet grill and place it inside, not touching the water pan. Make sure the turkey is not exposed to any direct heat, only indirect heat (which is how all pellet grills are set up but I know some readers smoke turkeys on a charcoal grill over indirect heat with wood chips.)

Then insert the instant read thermometer probe into the thickest part of the breast, and place the other end into the pellet grill temperature probe inserts.

how to smoke turkey breast on a pit boss

If your pellet grill doesnt have a temperature probe for instant readings, you will want to use a basic meat thermometer probe connected to a digital read out, or I recommend the Meater wireless probe which goes into the thickest part of the turkey breast and communicates directly with an app on your phone…the app is pretty cool and will talk to you about your progress as the turkey smoke.

how to smoke turkey breast on a pit boss

Either way, we will only be smoking to temperature, not to time, so we need a temperature probe that can tell us when the internal temperature of the turkey is approaching 160 degrees.

When the probe is inserted, close the chamber and begin the cook!

Smoked BONELESS TURKEY BREAST on a PIT BOSS! | Pellet Grill Boneless Turkey Breast

FAQ

How long does it take to smoke a turkey breast on a Pit Boss pellet grill?

Transfer turkey to the grill and smoke for 3 to 3 ½ hours, or until an internal temperature of 165°F is reached, rotating after 1 ½ hours.

Is it better to smoke a turkey breast at 225 or 250?

325-350. It’s not a low and slow like a brisket or pork shoulder. Poultry soaks up the smoke flavor so you run the risk of having way too much smoke flavor if you go 225. Also 225 will never give you crispy skin.

How long does it take to smoke a turkey breast at 225 degrees?

Instructions
  1. Preheat smoker to 225°F.
  2. Wash turkey well and pat dry. …
  3. Ingredients. …
  4. Place on middle rack of smoker and smoke for 4 ½ to 5 hours, about 45 minutes per pound, or until internal temperature reaches 165°F.

Do you cover a turkey when smoking on a pellet grill?

Close the lid and smoke for around 30 minutes per pound. The turkey is done when it reaches a temperature of 165 degrees F.Oct 24, 2022

Leave a Comment