All products are independently selected by our editors. If you buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Whether for Thanksgiving, Christmas, or any celebratory meal, preparing a holiday feast requires you to prioritize. Maybe homemade mac and cheese is nonnegotiable, but you’re fine with stuffing from the box. Maybe you prefer cranberry sauce from a can. But there’s one dish that accepts no compromises: the Thanksgiving turkey.
If you want the juiciest possible bird, you’re going to want to learn how to brine a turkey. The process may take a little time (start at least 2 days ahead of the feast), but properly brining a turkey yields the juiciest, most succulent meat—no dryness here. This easy turkey brining method from chef Thomas Keller gives you the best of both worlds: the crispy skin of a dry-brined turkey, but the supreme juiciness of a wet-brined bird. How, you ask? Let’s get into it.
Brining a turkey is an essential process that helps ensure your bird turns out juicy flavorful and tender. While you can brine a turkey in various containers, a 5 gallon bucket from Home Depot is a popular choice for several reasons. In this comprehensive guide, I’ll explain why a 5 gallon bucket works so well and provide a step-by-step tutorial on how to properly brine your turkey using this method.
Why Use a 5 Gallon Bucket for Brining?
A 5 gallon bucket from Home Depot is the ideal vessel for brining a turkey for the following reasons:
-
Size – A standard 5 gallon bucket can easily fit a turkey up to 25 pounds This provides enough room for the bird and 1-2 gallons of brine
-
Food-safe – While not all Home Depot buckets are food-grade, they sell specific 5 gallon buckets made from FDA-approved, BPA-free plastic that won’t leach chemicals. Be sure to get one labeled as food-safe.
-
Affordable – At around $5, a 5 gallon Home Depot bucket is very budget-friendly. The optional $2 lid is also useful for covering the brine.
-
Portability – The bucket’s built-in handle makes transporting your turkey effortless. You can move it in and out of the fridge or cooler easily.
-
Leakproof – The sturdy plastic bucket won’t leak brine everywhere like some containers can. For extra protection, use a turkey brining bag inside.
-
Temperature – The bucket can be stored in a 40°F refrigerator or cooler to keep the brine and turkey at food-safe temps.
Step-by-Step Instructions
Follow these simple steps for successfully brining your turkey in a 5 gallon Home Depot bucket
1. Purchase a Food-Safe Bucket
Visit Home Depot and pick up a 5 gallon bucket designated as food-grade or food-safe. It should be made from BPA-free plastic. Optionally, grab a lid too.
2. Clean and Sanitize the Bucket
Thoroughly wash the bucket with hot soapy water. Scrub the interior with a bottle brush. Rinse several times. Sanitize by spraying with a bleach solution and let sit 10 minutes before rinsing again. Allow to fully air dry.
3. Make the Brine
Choose a basic brine recipe. The classic ratio is 1 cup kosher salt and 1/2 cup sugar per 1 gallon of water. Feel free to add aromatics like garlic, citrus, herbs and spices. Bring the brine to a boil, stirring until the salt and sugar fully dissolve. Remove from heat and let cool.
4. Place Turkey in Bucket
Set the thawed turkey inside the clean 5 gallon bucket. Slowly pour the cooled brine over the turkey until completely submerged. Weigh down with a plate if needed. Insert a brining bag if desired.
5. Refrigerate
Put the lid on the 5 gallon bucket containing the turkey and brine. Refrigerate for 8-24 hours, keeping the temperature at or below 40°F. Add ice packs to the fridge or cooler as needed.
6. Remove and Rinse
Once the brining time is complete, remove the turkey from the brine. Discard the used brine. Thoroughly rinse the turkey under cool water to remove excess salt. Pat dry.
7. Cook as Usual
The brined turkey is ready to be roasted, grilled, smoked or cooked following your favorite recipe. Enjoy the juicy, seasoned flavor!
Turkey Brining FAQs
Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about brining turkey in a 5 gallon bucket:
Why does brining make turkey juicier?
The salt in the brine helps retain moisture and seasons the meat all the way through. This prevents the turkey from drying out.
How much brine do I need?
Plan on 1-2 gallons of brine for every turkey. A 5 gallon bucket can hold this amount easily.
Can I reuse the brine?
It’s not recommended to reuse brine as it can contain harmful bacteria. However, you can use leftover brine as a flavorful soup base.
What if my turkey floats in the brine?
This is common. Weigh it down fully submerged using a plate, bowl or resealable bag filled with canned goods or water.
Is a brined turkey done sooner?
It may cook slightly faster since it’s moister. Always rely on a meat thermometer to confirm doneness, not just time.
Can I brine longer than 24 hours?
Brining longer than 24 hours doesn’t provide additional benefits and can make the turkey overly salty. Stick to the recommended timing.
Do I still baste a brined turkey?
Basting helps crisp and brown the skin. But since a brined turkey is already seasoned and moist inside, basting is not required.
Enjoy the Benefits of a Perfectly Brined Bird
By brining your turkey in a 5 gallon food-safe bucket from Home Depot, you’ll enjoy a bird that’s incredibly juicy, tender and packed with flavor. The process is easy to follow using this handy guide. Be sure to stick to food safety guidelines for proper temperature control. Now relax and let the brine work its magic – your Thanksgiving turkey will be a guaranteed hit!
Wet brine vs. dry brine:
You have two ways to go here: the wet-brining method or the dry-brining method. Dry-brining involves rubbing a turkey with salt (and possibly some aromatics), then allowing the skin to dry out in the fridge overnight or for up to 3 days. This method is best for achieving crispy skin—but if you want an extra-juicy bird, consider the wet brine.
Wet-brining involves soaking a turkey in a saltwater solution overnight, resulting in an incredibly flavorful bird, plump with moisture. A raw turkey left to soak in unsalted water will plump some, but when there’s salt present, the proteins absorb more of the brine and retain more of that water as it cooks. For example, a 12-pound turkey soaked overnight in a wet brine will weigh over 13 pounds when it emerges. In the oven this added moisture will offset the juices released during roasting, resulting in a very moist bird. A wet brine also provides an opportunity for introducing additional flavors—think apple cider, maple syrup, chile peppers, or star anise.
Detractors of wet brining complain a wet-brined bird can be slow to brown. But Keller’s foolproof method includes a smart final step that results in extra-crispy skin.