How Much Does a Butterball Turkey Cost? A Complete Pricing Guide

As Thanksgiving and Christmas approach, many people start thinking about how to get the perfect turkey as the centerpiece for their holiday meals. For decades, Butterball has been one of the most trusted and popular turkey brands in America. With their reputation for moist, tender and delicious turkeys, it’s no wonder so many home cooks choose Butterball for their holiday feasts.

But Butterball offers a wide range of turkey sizes, so how do you know which one fits your budget? Here is a comprehensive guide to Butterball turkey pricing so you can easily figure out how much a Butterball turkey costs on average.

Factors That Determine Butterball Turkey Prices

Several key factors impact the retail pricing for whole Butterball turkeys

• Weight – Butterball offers whole turkeys ranging from 10 to 24 pounds typically. The larger the turkey, the higher the price per pound due to more meat.

• Self-Basting vs Natural – Self-basting Butterball turkeys are pre-injected with a salt solution to keep them moist Natural turkeys with no additives are slightly less expensive,

• Frozen vs. Fresh – Frozen Butterball turkeys are more budget-friendly than fresh never-frozen turkeys which are considered premium.

• Specialty vs. Standard – Heritage breed or organic turkeys command a higher price than standard supermarket turkey varieties.

• Time of Year – Turkey prices hit their peak around Thanksgiving and Christmas. Prices are lowest in the off-season early in the year.

• Store Promotions – Look for holiday promotions, loyalty card discounts and markdowns to save on Butterball turkeys.

Average Butterball Turkey Prices

Here are the average price ranges for whole Butterball turkeys:

Frozen Butterball Turkeys:

• 10-12 lb turkeys: $1.29 – $1.79 per lb
• 14-16 lb turkeys: $1.19 – $1.69 per lb
• 18-20 lb turkeys: $1.09 – $1.59 per lb
• 22-24 lb turkeys: $0.99 – $1.49 per lb

Fresh Butterball Turkeys:

• 10-12 lb turkeys: $1.69 – $1.99 per lb
• 14-16 lb turkeys: $1.59 – $1.89 per lb
• 18-20 lb turkeys: $1.49 – $1.79 per lb
• 22-24 lb turkeys: $1.39 – $1.69 per lb

Specialty Butterball Turkeys:

• Organic & heirloom varieties: $3.99 – $5.99 per lb
• Kosher turkeys: $2.99 – $3.99 per lb
• Other premium turkeys: $1.99 – $2.99 per lb

Estimated Total Prices by Turkey Size

Use these typical price ranges for common Butterball turkey sizes to estimate the total cost:

• 10-12 lb turkey: $13 – $22
• 14-16 lb turkey: $17 – $27
• 18-20 lb turkey: $20 – $32
• 22-24 lb turkey: $22 – $36

Larger gatherings will need bigger birds while smaller groups can save with a more reasonably sized turkey.

Where to Find the Best Butterball Turkey Prices

Here are some of the best retailers for getting the most affordable Butterball turkey deals:

• Walmart – Excellent everyday low prices on frozen Butterball turkeys.

• Aldi – Discounter carries frozen Butterball turkeys for less.

• Kroger – Frequent holiday promotions and loyalty card deals on Butterball.

• Costco – Big savings when you buy large, bulk frozen Butterball turkeys.

• Amazon – Competitive Butterball turkey pricing with free Prime shipping.

• Dollar General – Budget-friendly fresh and frozen turkeys under $1 per lb.

• Butterball Website – Online discounts and sales with direct frozen turkey delivery.

Tips for Saving on Your Butterball

Follow these tips to keep your Butterball turkey purchase affordable:

• Buy the biggest turkey that will comfortably feed your group to maximize price per pound.

• Shop early and stock up – frozen turkeys store for long periods.

• Avoid last-minute grocery trips when demand can spike turkey costs.

• Use grocery flyers, digital coupons and loyalty cards for turkey deals.

• Look for post-holiday sales to buy turkeys well in advance.

Is a Butterball Worth the Price?

Butterball turkeys earn their reputation for moist, delicious flavor and cooking ease. While you’ll pay slightly more than generic brands, the consistency and quality are worth it for many home cooks. With smart shopping strategies, you can easily find great bargains on Butterball turkeys.

Recent Butterball Turkey Prices at Major Retailers

To give a current snapshot of Butterball turkey prices, here are some examples from major national retailers:

Target

• Butterball Premium All Natural Young Turkey, Frozen, 20-24 lbs – $1.29/lb

Walmart

• Butterball Frozen Whole Turkey, 10-12 lbs – $13.94 ($1.39/lb)
• Butterball Fresh Whole Turkey, 22-24 lbs – $33.62 ($1.40/lb)

Aldi

• Butterball Frozen Turkey, 10-16 lbs – $1.07/lb

Kroger

• Butterball Frozen Turkey, 14-22 lbs – $0.67/lb with digital coupon

Amazon

• Butterball Frozen Turkey, 12-14 lbs – $1.40/lb

So you can typically find frozen Butterball turkeys for around $1.00-$1.50 per pound from major retailers. Watch for holiday promotions that can bring the per pound price down even lower.

The Bottom Line

Butterball turkeys offer time-tested quality and flavor for your holiday meals. With the pricing factors and shopping tips above, you can easily navigate the wide range of Butterball options to find the perfect turkey for your gathering and budget. Sizing up Butterball turkeys well in advance helps ensure you get the bird you want at the price you want to pay.