If you find yourself with a frozen turkey on Thanksgiving morning, relax. You can still have a beautiful, flavorful, juicy bird for your holiday feast…really! We have the time and temperature tips you need for a picture-perfect turkey direct from frozen when you’re in a pinch.
Extra dinner guests show up unexpectedly? Forget to pull the turkey from the freezer? Whatever the reason why your turkey is still frozen solid, don’t fret. You should never cook a partially frozen turkey because the outer layers of turkey will become a desert while the frozen center thaws and comes to a safe temperature, but if thawing isn’t an option, a completely frozen turkey can still be the centerpiece of your holiday meal.
Smoking a turkey is a great way to add delicious flavor and make your holiday centerpiece really stand out But what if you forgot to thaw the bird ahead of time? Is it safe to smoke a frozen turkey?
The short answer is no. Smoking a frozen turkey can lead to uneven cooking and bacteria growth putting you and your guests at risk of food poisoning.
In this article, we’ll explain why you should never smoke a frozen turkey and give you some safer alternatives for getting perfectly smoked turkey flavor – even if you’re short on time.
Why You Should Never Smoke a Frozen Turkey
There are a few important reasons why smoking a frozen turkey is dangerous:
Uneven Cooking
Smoking relies on indirect heat and longer cook times at lower temperatures. A frozen turkey won’t thaw and cook evenly when smoked. The outer areas will appear cooked while the inside remains frozen.
Bacteria Growth
A frozen turkey takes much longer to come up to a safe internal temperature when smoked. This extended time in the “danger zone” between 40-140°F allows bacteria like salmonella to quickly multiply.
Inconsistent Internal Temp
Smoking doesn’t allow you to guarantee that all parts of a frozen turkey reach the safe minimum internal temperature of 165°F needed to kill harmful bacteria.
Cross-Contamination
Trying to quickly thaw a turkey in the microwave or hot water leads to uneven thawing. The outer areas thaw first while the inner cavity remains frozen. Partial thawing also increases the risk of Salmonella spreading in your kitchen.
The only way to safely prep a frozen turkey is with a slow thaw in the refrigerator over 24-36 hours.
So if you forgot to plan ahead and thaw your turkey, smoking is off the table. But don’t worry, you still have some options for getting smoked flavor without the risk.
Safer Alternatives for Smoked Turkey Flavor
If you don’t have time to fully thaw your turkey before the big meal, try these safer alternatives:
Cook It in the Oven
Cooking a frozen turkey in the oven is safe, it just takes longer. Plan for about 50% extra cooking time. The turkey won’t have the same smoky flavor, but you can add smoke via other methods.
Try a Smaller Bird
Opt for a smaller turkey breast that will thaw faster. A bone-in breast only needs about 12 hours to thaw compared to 24+ for a full bird.
Use Smoked Turkey Parts
Cook thawed turkey parts like drumsticks, thighs or wings on the smoker. Mix with oven roasted white meat for a full smoked turkey effect.
Go Fully Cooked
Buy a ready-to-eat fully cooked smoked turkey and simply reheat it on the day. This lets you skip the smoking and thawing worries altogether.
Make Smoked Turkey Breast
Hot smoke a thawed turkey breast for 2-3 hours until it reaches 165°F internally. Slice it up and serve just the smoked white meat.
Use Liquid Smoke
Add liquid smoke flavoring to your gravy, stuffing or brine to infuse everything with smoky taste without actually smoking the bird.
Smoke The Sides
Smoke compatible sides like onions, garlic, carrots or potatoes. The smoky aroma and flavor will come through even without smoking the main protein.
Tips for Safely Smoking Turkey
When you do have time to fully thaw your turkey and smoke it properly, follow these tips for success:
-
Always thaw in the fridge: Allow 24 hours of thawing time per 5 lbs of turkey.
-
Dry brine: Rubbing the turkey all over with salt and spices a day before smoking enhances flavor.
-
Don’t stuff: Stuffing prevents air circulation and leads to uneven cooking. Cook it separately.
-
Use a meat thermometer: Insert a probe thermometer into the deepest part of the thigh to monitor temp.
-
Aim for 165°F: The turkey is safe to eat once it registers 165°F in both the thigh and breast.
-
Let it rest: Letting the smoked turkey rest for 30 minutes before carving allows juices to redistribute.
Smoking a tasty turkey for the holidays takes planning. As long as you properly thaw the bird and use a meat thermometer to confirm doneness, you’ll have a mouthwatering centerpiece the whole family will love.
If you do get caught with a frozen bird, resist the temptation to smoke it frozen. Following the safer alternatives we covered will still let you enjoy delicious smoked turkey flavor without risking food poisoning to you and your holiday guests.
Benefits of Cooking a Frozen Turkey
- Won’t the white meat overcook? Actually, when you cook a fully frozen turkey, the breasts are the largest muscles on the turkey and will take the longest time to thaw, cook, and to come to their pull temperature. The relatively smaller legs and thighs will thaw and cook faster from their frozen state, giving them more time for connective tissue to dissolve. The white and dark meat will cook properly and you may find your turkey is less likely to have dry breast meat than when you cook a thawed turkey.
- Refrigerator Space: No thawing means no turkey taking up space in your fridge and no stressful thawing process.
Challenges and Considerations with Frozen Turkeys
A Longer Cook Time: Just as you would expect, a frozen turkey will take longer to cook than one that is thawed before being placed in the oven. Plan on it taking approximately 50% more time to cook completely—so be aware that your dinner may be served later than originally planned. For example, our 14-pound turkey cooked in 5-3/4 hours.- Oven Temp to Set? Set your oven temperature too low and the outer meat will overcook. Set it too high and you’ll end up with the same problem encountered when cooking a partially frozen turkey (dry, overcooked outer breast meat when the thermal center finally reaches your pull temp). A moderate oven temperature of 325°F (163°C) is the sweet spot.
Q: Can I smoke a frozen turkey?
A: No. Remember that the USDA recommends that turkey needs to be out of the danger zone within 4 hours of the turkey being taken out of the freezer or refrigerator. The temperatures of smoking (225-275°F [107-135°C]) are too low to cook a frozen turkey to a food safe temperature within 4 hours.
Q: Can I deep-fry a frozen turkey?
A: NO!! NEVER. The dramatic temperature difference between the hot oil and the frozen turkey will cause violent boil overs. Oil spilling over the top edge of the pot could ignite with the flame from the burner below. Trying to deep-fry a frozen turkey is what causes explosions. The turkey must be COMPLETELY thawed and patted dry before being deep-fried. Read our post, Deep Fried Turkey Made Safe and Delicious for more information on how to safely deep fry a turkey.
So here’s how to take a turkey from a block of ice to a picture-perfect centerpiece:
How To Smoke a Frozen Turkey For Thanksgiving, No Thaw?
FAQ
Is it okay to smoke a frozen turkey?
First things first: You cannot smoke a frozen turkey. Because smoking is at low temperatures, even a thawed turkey is going to cook very slowly.Oct 25, 2019
Do you have to thaw a turkey before smoking?
It’s not safe to smoke a frozen turkey. Make sure the bird is fully thawed before smoking. This ensures even cooking and reduces the risk of harmful bacteria growth.
Can you cook a frozen turkey without thawing?
- Longer cooking time: Expect to cook a frozen turkey for roughly 50% longer than a thawed one.
- No need to brine: Some brands recommend not brining a frozen turkey before cooking.
- Use a meat thermometer: Always use a meat thermometer to ensure the turkey reaches a safe internal temperature of 165°F in the breast and thigh.
- Check for brand instructions: Some turkey brands specifically market “cook from frozen” options, so check the packaging for specific guidelines.
Can you smoke a butterball cook from frozen turkey?
Frozen Whole Turkeys and Frozen Whole Turkey Breasts need to be thawed before cooking. Thaw Fully Cooked Baked and Smoked Turkeys via the refrigerator method. Refrigerator thawing is preferred and the least labor-intensive but requires more time.