It’s almost as healthy to choose a turkey burger over a beef burger as it is to switch from regular french fries to sweet potato fries.
At least that’s how we usually see it, which comes from the idea that ground turkey is always better for you than ground beef.
Also, turkey burger patties aren’t just ground turkey; they need other things to keep their shape and moisture. So, is ordering a turkey burger really the healthier option we all want it to be?
Turkey burgers have become an increasingly popular alternative to traditional beef burgers. With concerns over saturated fat and red meat intake many opt for turkey patties in hopes of a healthier option. But how do turkey burgers really compare to beef in terms of nutrition, taste, and overall quality? Let’s take a close look at the pros cons, and key considerations when choosing turkey burgers.
Nutritional Comparison of Turkey and Beef Burgers
There is a common perception that turkey burgers are inherently healthier than beef. However, when you compare their nutrition profiles, the differences are more nuanced. Here are some key points:
-
Lean turkey and beef have similar protein content. Switching from beef to turkey does not significantly affect protein intake
-
Ground turkey can have just as much fat as beef depending on the leanness Be sure to read labels and choose 93-95% lean turkey,
-
Turkey contains less saturated fat. This makes it a slightly better choice for heart health.
-
Beef provides more iron and zinc than turkey. These are important nutrients, so enjoy beef in moderation.
-
Turkey and beef burgers can have similar calories when portion sizes are equal. Focus on reasonable patty sizes and toppings.
Overall, turkey does contain less saturated fat than beef. But when lean options are chosen for both, the differences become minor. Portion control and cooking method have a bigger impact on the final nutrition figures.
How Do Turkey Burgers Taste in Comparison to Beef?
The most common complaint about turkey burgers is dryness and lack of flavor. Because turkey is a lean meat, it can easily become dried out and bland. Here are some tips to keep turkey burgers juicy and delicious:
-
Choose 93% lean ground turkey to retain some fat for moisture. Going above 95% lean can become overly dry.
-
Mix in a small amount of breadcrumbs or egg to help bind the meat. This adds texture and moisture.
-
Season the turkey patties well with spices like garlic, onion, paprika, salt, and pepper. Boosting flavor counters the mildness.
-
Cook the burgers to 165°F, but no higher to prevent overdrying. Use a meat thermometer for accuracy.
-
Consider basting the patties with a flavorful sauce or oil while cooking to add juiciness.
-
Opt for flavor boosting toppings like guacamole, savory sautéed onions, or a zesty aioli spread.
With the right techniques and ingredients, turkey burger texture and moisture can match or even surpass beef burgers. The key is keeping them from drying out.
Are Store-Bought Turkey Burgers a Healthy Option?
Pre-made frozen turkey burger patties can seem like a convenient shortcut. However, they often contain questionable additives and fillers. Here are some drawbacks of store-bought turkey burgers:
-
Added sodium from preservatives can be sky-high, sometimes over 800mg per patty. Choose no-salt-added versions.
-
Fillers and binders like wheat flour or cornstarch add refined carbs and little nutrition. Check the ingredient list.
-
Vegetable oils, soy protein, maltodextrin, and modified food starch are common. These overly processed ingredients are best limited.
-
Lean ground turkey is naturally affordable. Homemade patties avoid unnecessary additives.
When choosing pre-made turkey burger patties, go for options with the fewest, most natural ingredients. Making them at home lets you control exactly what goes into them.
Tips for the Best Turkey Burgers
Follow these simple tips for turkey burgers that are juicy, flavorful, and nutritious:
-
Choose 93-95% lean ground turkey for the right balance of moisture and leanness.
-
Mix in a small amount of panko breadcrumbs and egg to help bind the patties.
-
Season the turkey generously with garlic, onion, spices, salt, and pepper.
-
Cook to 165°F internal temperature using a meat thermometer to prevent drying out.
-
Baste with olive oil or brush with barbecue sauce for extra moisture and caramelized flavor.
-
Avoid overloading with high-fat cheeses or creamy sauces and spreads which can undo the benefits.
-
Opt for whole grain buns and load up with veggie toppings like lettuce, tomato, onion, and avocado.
Turkey burgers can absolutely be juicy, flavorful and satisfying when prepared with care. Choosing turkey over beef occasionally can help limit saturated fat and tailor nutrition to your needs. With the right cooking methods and toppings, turkey burgers can be an enjoyable alternative to standard beef burgers. Give them a try!
What about everything else added to turkey burger patties, though?
Anyone who has made turkey patties at home knows that breadcrumbs are almost always needed, even in healthy turkey burger recipes.
Compared to a ground beef patty, which can be shaped by rolling and flattening, this could be a nutrition concern for turkey burgers. Is the high-carb ingredient in your turkey burger patties making them less healthy, especially since they’ll be put between two slices of bread?
“The amount of breadcrumbs in the patties is really very small compared to the amount of ground turkey,” says Beaver. “That quarter cup of breadcrumbs, panko, or crushed crackers isn’t going to make a big difference in the nutrition of a turkey burger, so don’t worry about it.” “.
Another option is subbing egg for the breadcrumbs.
“I like to add a little of both,” Beaver says. “The egg helps hold the ground turkey together, and the breadcrumbs make it more tender and probably add some flavor as well.”
How to a build a healthy burger — whether turkey or beef
“Just because the burger is turkey does not automatically mean it is healthier,” Beaver adds.
Whether you go for turkey or beef, here are Beavers five tips for a healthy burger:
Grass-Fed Beef Burgers vs. Turkey Burgers: Which Is Healtheir?
FAQ
Does turkey burger taste good?
Are turkey burgers better than beef burgers?
Are turkey burgers better than chicken?
Does ground turkey taste better than beef?
Should you buy a turkey burger?
Buying turkey can be tricky and if you aren’t careful, it can actually have a much higher fat and calories than you think (or if you end up using all breast turkey, your burger can be super dry!). Whichever type of burger you choose, keep cooked patties at 4-ounces with modestly portioned toppings to keep your meal on the healthier side.
What are the health benefits of ground turkey?
Ground turkey has multiple benefits. It is a good source of minerals, and B vitamins, rich in proteins, low in fat and it is lower in calories than common turkey.
Is a turkey burger healthier than a beef burger?
As far as healthy food swaps go, choosing a turkey burger over a beef burger is right up there with subbing regular french fries for sweet potato ones. Or that’s how we often see it anyway — a perception rooted in the larger assumption that ground turkey is always healthier than ground beef. But how different are these ground meats really?
Should you eat a turkey burger at a restaurant?
At a restaurant, all bets are off, Villacorta explains. Ground turkey dries out more easily than ground beef. So to keep your burger juicy, restaurants tend to load up their turkey burgers with fat and unhealthy condiments. “A restaurant is a lot more concerned about taste than whether it’s healthy,” Villacorta says.
Are turkey burgers bad for You?
There are a few potential downsides to keep in mind: They can be dry – Without enough fat, turkey burgers can end up dry, dense, and bland. Extra care must be taken to keep them tender and juicy. Risk of foodborne illness – Just like beef, undercooked turkey poses a risk for salmonella and should be cooked to an internal temperature of 165°F.
What makes a good turkey burger?
Finding a reliably delicious option takes effort. More processed – Most commercial turkey burgers contain added binders, fillers, and stabilizers for texture. They are often more processed than all-beef patties. Higher cost – Pound for pound, turkey tends to be pricier than 80/20 ground beef.