What is the Difference Between Chicken Noodle Soup and Ramen?
Chicken noodle soup and ramen are two of the most popular and comforting soups globally. Both soups feature noodles in broth yet they have distinct differences in history ingredients, preparation methods, flavor profiles, and cultural significance. This article will examine the key differences between traditional American chicken noodle soup and Japanese ramen.
Origins and History
Chicken noodle soup has its roots in European cuisine, especially Eastern European Jewish culinary traditions. The dish was likely brought over to America by Ashkenazi Jewish immigrants in the 19th and early 20th centuries. Chicken noodle soup became a staple comfort food across the United States by the 1950s. It remains a nostalgic classic often associated with being served when sick.
Ramen, on the other hand, came to Japan in the early 1900s and was first sold on the streets of Tokyo. Ramen was first based on Chinese wheat noodles, but it has since become a uniquely Japanese noodle soup. Its popularity spread through the mid 1900s. When it was first made in 1958, instant ramen was a cheap and stable food. Ramen restaurants also began growing in major Japanese cities. Today, ramen enjoys worldwide popularity.
Ingredients
The clear broth in chicken noodle soup comes from cooking chicken and vegetables like onions, carrots, and celery for a long time. Egg noodles, shredded chicken, and spices like salt, pepper, parsley, and bay leaves are also in it.
Ramen features a richer, cloudier broth made by boiling pork, chicken, and dried fish for many hours. It also contains curly wheat noodles, toppings like sliced pork, dried seaweed, menma (fermented bamboo shoots), green onions, and a soft boiled egg. Seasonings include soy sauce, miso paste, and sesame oil.
Preparation Methods
Chicken and vegetables are simmered for one to two hours to make chicken noodle soup broth. The egg noodles cook within the soup for 5-10 minutes. Before serving, any chicken is poached in the broth as well.
Ramen broth requires 12-24 hours of boiling bones and meat. The curly noodles are usually fried before serving. Toppings are added to the piping hot broth just before eating so they retain texture and color. Ramen preparation is more complex and time consuming.
Nutrition
Homemade chicken noodle soup using lean chicken, lots of vegetables and whole wheat noodles can be a nutritious low-calorie, low-fat meal. Depending on portion size, it provides protein, vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants.
Instant ramen is high in sodium, saturated fat, and calories, with little nutritional value. Some gourmet ramen shops offer healthier options with whole grain noodles, leaner broth, and plentiful veggies. Pay attention to the ingredient list when choosing ramen.
Flavors
Chicken noodle soup has a light, clear savory broth that highlights basic flavors like chicken, salt, pepper, and herbs. Egg noodles provide mild starchiness. Overall, it’s a simple, comforting flavor.
Ramen broth is rich, thick, and complex from long simmering. It provides deep savory umami flavors. Curly noodles have a springy, chewy texture. When topped with different things, ramen has a very intense, complex flavor.
Convenience
Chicken noodle soup can be prepared in under an hour at home using simple ingredients. Canned chicken broth and noodles make it even easier. Dried soup mixes allow quick stove-top preparation.
Ramen shops allow enjoying fresh made-to-order bowls. Instant ramen just needs hot water for a quick comforting meal. However, authentic homemade ramen broth requires significant time and effort. Good ramen is labor intensive.
Cultural Significance
Chicken noodle soup is a nostalgic comfort food in America, often associated with being served to sick children. It’s seen as a soothing, nurturing dish.
In Japan, ramen is considered an artisanal food and subject of regional pride and rivalry. Ramen shops are popular gathering places. Devoted “ramen otaku” make pilgrimages to famous ramen towns like Tokyo, Sapporo, and Fukuoka to sample different styles. Ramen is a cultural icon.
Customization
Chicken noodle soup can be tailored by using different vegetables, grains like barley or rice noodles, adding more protein or using various spices.
Ramen can be customized with infinite broth flavors, toppings like grilled meats or vegetables, spice pastes, specialty oils, and noodles like soba or udon. Limited only by imagination and regional ramen style constraints.
What’s the difference between ramen and noodles?
As instant noodles and ramen gain popularity in the international market, it is important to understand the differences between these two noodles. In the United States, ramen is incorrectly defined as a generic phrase for quick noodles. Ramen is a type of noodle soup from Japan. Because of its origins in China, it was previously known as shina soba, literally “Chinese soba. ” Historians aren’t sure when the shift to Japan occurred.
Noodle is an umbrella term, noodles are made with dough and typically, this dough is created with wheat flour, rice, beans, or starch. The dough is also mixed with water and salt. These shapes are made by cutting, extruding, or stretching. On the other hand, to constitute a noodle as ramen, however, is a different story. A bowl of ramen must have noodles that are made of flour, kansui, and water. Authentic raw ramen noodles and instant ramen noodles are both made out of these ingredients.
Ramen is a type of noodle soup from Japan. Because of its origins in China, it was previously known as shina soba, literally “Chinese soba. ” Historians aren’t sure when the shift to Japan occurred. Ramen is traditionally cooked with hand-pulled wheat noodles in chicken or pork broth and topped with scallions, bamboo shoots, and sliced barbecue pork. However, there are several geographical variants.
Ramen is traditionally cooked with hand-pulled wheat noodles in chicken or pork broth and topped with scallions, bamboo shoots, and sliced barbecue pork. However, there are several geographical variants.
Read more: The 5 Components of Ramen
Momofuku Ando discovered how to dehydrate noodles in his shed in 1958, and thus instant noodles were born. When instant noodles first became accessible in Japan, they were slightly more expensive than fresh ramen and were regarded as a luxury item. When Ando was able to mass-produce instant noodles, they became more affordable.
Instant noodles are now distinguished by a distinct spice packet and convenience of preparation. There are also instant noodles available, ranging from bowl and cup noodles to instant udon and soba. The only thing that quick noodles and ramen have in common is that they are both noodle soups. Ramen is created from scratch, whereas instant noodles are made from a wide selection of prefabricated noodles. Think about it the next time you name something ramen. Is it ramen or are they quick noodles?.
Phở vs Ramen : What’s The Difference?
FAQ
Is ramen and Noodle Soup the same thing?
Ramen is a particular type of noodle, so it’s a noodle soup. But not all noodle soups are ramen.
Can I use ramen noodles for chicken noodle soup?
Saute onions, carrots and celery, cook for 4 minutes. When vegetables are brown, add water and bring to a boil. Add MMG ramen noodles, soup base, seasoning oil and chicken. Cook until chicken is fully cooked and noodles are soft.
How is ramen different from noodles?
Difference in ingredients: Ramen is made with wheat flour, salt, water, and a type of alkaline water called kansui. This last ingredient is what sets them apart from regular noodles. Noodles, on the other hand, are made using the first three ingredients alone.
Is chicken ramen a soup?
Ramen is a Japanese adaptation of Chinese wheat noodle soups. It is first recorded to have appeared in Yokohama Chinatown in the early 20th century.