It used to be that beef tallow was one of the most popular fats for cooking. It makes food taste rich and savory, which is a good thing. Still, it’s not as popular as it used to be because it has a lot of saturated fat, which is bad for your health. This has led to a huge demand for cooking alternatives that use vegetable oil.
But once in a while, you’ll see a recipe that calls for beef tallow, and you may be confused about what else you can use instead. Luckily, there are options. From plant-based alternatives to other animal fats, here are our 5 best beef tallow substitutes for any situation!.
Beef dripping is the rendered fat collected from cooking beef, often used for flavoring and cooking. If you don’t have any on hand or want to try something new, there are plenty of great substitutes for beef dripping.
From butter to bacon grease, different fats can mimic the rich, meaty quality of beef dripping Let’s explore some of the best options to use when beef dripping isn’t available.
Why Use Beef Dripping?
First, what makes beef dripping worth using in the first place? This fat imparts dishes with:
- Rich, savory beef flavor
- Silky texture
- Hearty mouthfeel
- Lovely browning when used for sautéing
Dripping adds more richness than oil or butter. The beefy notes enhance pot roasts, Yorkshire puddings, gravies, roasts, fries, and more
Home cooks save dripping from roasts or steaks to reuse But not everyone has this on hand when a recipe calls for it Luckily, there are plenty of tasty ways to mimic beefy flavor and richness without actual dripping.
Butter
Butter is a top choice to substitute for beef dripping thanks to its luscious texture and richness. Use it in the same amount called for in the recipe.
Clarified butter has a higher smoke point so it’s great for sautéing. Regular butter provides that irresistible creaminess.
While butter doesn’t have an inherently beefy flavor, it complements and enhances the other ingredients. Dishes like mashed potatoes turn out smooth and satiny with a pat of butter.
If substituting in baked goods, butter provides similar richness and moisture. Treat it as a 1:1 swap for beef dripping.
Coconut Oil
Coconut oil has a subtle tropical essence that pairs surprisingly well with beef flavors. Use virgin, unrefined coconut oil to get the most flavor.
This plant-based fat remains solid at room temperature like beef tallow. And it holds up well under heat with a smoke point around 350°F.
Coconut oil has a smooth, creamy consistency for making tender baked goods. Try using it in meat pies or savory scones in place of dripping.
Start by substituting a 1:1 ratio of solid coconut oil for beef fat. You may need to experiment to get the perfect texture.
Vegetable Shortening
Vegetable shortening contains plant-based fats that mimic the rich mouthfeel of animal fats. Use it for baking flaky biscuits or pastry dough.
Shortening remains firm at room temperature, creaming well with sugar. It gives a soft, thick texture to cookies, scones, and pie crusts.
For savory dishes, note that vegetable shortening has a neutral flavor. Mix in beef broth or bullion when sautéing to impart a meaty taste.
Replace beef dripping with an equal amount of shortening, adjusting to achieve the ideal texture.
Lard
Lard is rendered pork fat, making it an excellent stand-in for beef dripping. It has a similar richness along with a subtle pork flavor.
Use lard for pie crusts, biscuits, cookies, fried chicken, tamales, and anywhere else you’d use dripping. It makes food tender and moist with a delicate crispness.
Lard has a high smoke point of about 370-400°F, so it’s great for frying and sautéing too. For the best results, look for high-quality lard from pasture-raised pigs.
Olive Oil
Don’t overlook olive oil as an option for mimicking beef dripping. Good quality extra virgin olive oil has a pleasant fruitiness that complements beef.
For sautéing, use an olive oil with a high smoke point to avoid burning it. The bold flavor stands up well to beef.
In baked goods, substitute a fruity olive oil cup for cup in place of beef dripping. It adds moisture and richness while allowing beefy flavors to still shine.
Duck Fat
For an especially decadent alternative, turn to duck fat. This bird fat has a richness resembling beef tallow.
Duck fat adds luxurious texture and flavor to dishes like duck confit, potatoes, and more. Use it anywhere you’d typically use beef dripping.
The subtle sweet, nutty taste pairs beautifully with beef. Duck fat has a high smoke point, so it’s also great for high-heat cooking.
Bacon Grease
Lastly, don’t pour that leftover bacon grease down the drain! Save those drippings to use as a smoky, porky alternative to beef dripping.
Bacon grease has a lower smoke point, so it’s not the best for frying. But it adds incredible flavor to roasted vegetables, gravies, biscuits, green beans, and more.
Mix a few spoonfuls of bacon grease into the beef dripping substitute of your choice too. This amplifies the savory meatiness.
Experiment with Different Fats
When you run out of beef dripping, don’t despair! With various fats, you can mimic the luxurious mouthfeel and rich flavor in your cooking and baking.
Butter, lard, olive oil, coconut oil, duck fat, bacon grease – play around with different substitutes. You may find a new favorite.
Use your senses as a guide. Look for fats that remain solid at room temperature and turn golden brown when cooked. Taste test as you go to get the perfect balance of richness.
With the right beef dripping alternative, your food will still turn out tender, juicy, and full of flavor. So next time a recipe calls for this particular fat, try experimenting with a tasty substitute.
Best All-Around Substitute For Beef Tallow: Lard And Shmaltz.
Lard is an excellent substitute for beef tallow. Usually, it is made with rendered pig fat, but it can also be made from other animal fats. It has a similar consistency and flavor to beef tallow, making it a great alternative for cooking.
Schmaltz is another good substitute for beef tallow. It’s a type of rendered chicken fat popular in Jewish cooking. It has a mild flavor and can be used in any dish where beef tallow is typically used.
The only difference between the two is that one tastes a little like pork and the other like chicken, while beef tallow tastes very much like beef. Think of it like using a chicken stock cube in a recipe that calls for a beef one…. it’s still going to add flavor, it’ll just be a little different!.
Best Beef Tallow Substitute for Regular Cooking: Lard And Shmaltz
You can cook with lard and schmaltz over normal heat, but not over high heat because their smoke points aren’t high enough and they burn. They both have a rich flavor and heartiness that I haven’t been able to find in any other vegan food.
Schmaltz adds depth to all kinds of cooking, but it works especially well with roasting potatoes and vegetables. Lard is good in gravy, pastry, and stews.
5 Ways Tallow (Beef Fat) Can Help You Lose Weight
FAQ
What is a good substitute for beef dripping for Yorkshire puddings?
What is a substitute for roast drippings?
Is beef dripping the same as butter?
What is a good substitute for beef dripping?
Lard is a good substitute for beef dripping in cooking and baking. It has a similar consistency to beef dripping and can be used in most recipes that call for it. Goose fat is also a good source of vitamins and minerals, such as vitamin A, vitamin K, and calcium.
What is the healthier substitute of brisket?
Brisket is high in fat. Instead of brisket, lean meat like chicken, turkey and fish will be a good option for healthy lifestyle. Chicken is good source of protein and has very less fat. Omega-3-fatty acids are good for healthy heart, which we used to get from fish.
Can I use butter instead of beef dripping?
When using butter instead of beef dripping in a recipe, it is important to use the same amount of butter as the recipe calls for. This will help maintain the same flavor and texture as the dish would have with beef dripping.
Can you use olive oil instead of beef dripping?
Vegetable oils like canola oil or olive oil can be used in equal amounts as beef dripping in most recipes. However, keep in mind that they may slightly alter the texture and consistency of your dishes. Beef tallow can be an excellent substitute for beef dripping in many recipes.