A 16-year-old young man had developed severe acne, and his case had stumped his treating physician. Why? Because his acne just wasn’t responding to treatment.
Because his acne was so bad, his dermatologist told him to start taking Accutane, a strong prescription acne medicine. Unfortunately, even with this powerful medication, his acne just wasn’t getting better.
At a loss for what to do next, his dermatologist asked him again about his medical history. Was he taking any prescription medications at all? No, he wasn’t. “The only thing I take is whey protein powder because I’m trying to build more muscle. ”.
Whey protein powder: it turns out that this commonly sold supplement was the culprit. His acne finally improved once he completely stopped whey protein and switched to a non-dairy product.
Acne is a common skin condition that affects people of all ages. It is characterized by pimples blackheads, whiteheads and deeper cysts or nodules that appear on the face, neck, chest, back, shoulders and upper arms. Acne can be mild, moderate or severe. While acne is not life-threatening, it can cause emotional distress, especially in teens and young adults.
Many factors contribute to acne, including genetics hormones excess oil production, stress, and certain medications. There has also been a lot of debate around whether diet plays a role in acne development. In particular, there are claims that certain proteins like whey and beef protein can trigger breakouts.
In this article, we’ll take an in-depth look at the evidence to determine if beef protein causes acne.
What is Beef Protein?
Beef protein is a protein supplement derived from cow’s milk. The most common forms are beef protein isolate and beef protein concentrate.
Beef protein contains all 9 essential amino acids needed to stimulate muscle protein synthesis. It is often marketed as a high quality, fast-absorbing protein source for building muscle mass.
Compared to other proteins like whey and soy, beef protein is generally more expensive and less commonly used. However, some people prefer using beef protein if they have issues digesting other protein sources.
Does Dairy Cause Acne?
Before examining beef protein specifically, it’s important to address whether dairy in general can trigger acne. Dairy products like milk, cheese, yogurt and whey protein come from cow’s milk.
Several large observational studies have found a link between drinking milk and acne risk in teenagers. However, the evidence is mixed when it comes to adults. Two large studies involving over 10,000 adults found no association between dairy intake and acne.
There are a few reasons why dairy may contribute to acne:
-
Hormones: Cow’s milk contains hormones like insulin growth factor 1 (IGF-1), which may stimulate oil production and clog pores. However, levels of IGF-1 in milk are extremely low.
-
Inflammation: Some dairy proteins may trigger inflammation, which can worsen acne. People with milk allergies appear more prone to acne.
-
Fat Content: High fat dairy products may increase sebum production. Skim milk has been associated with worse acne compared to full fat milk.
Overall, there is no conclusive evidence showing dairy causes acne. Individual sensitivities vary greatly. Many people consume dairy daily with no effects on their skin.
Does Whey Protein Cause Acne?
Whey is the liquid part of milk that separates from the curds during cheese production. It is a popular protein supplement used by athletes and bodybuilders.
There are some anecdotal reports online of whey protein causing acne. However, no studies have proven a direct link between whey supplementation and increased acne.
Whey protein is absorbed quickly and causes a spike in insulin levels. Rapid rises in insulin may trigger increased oil production and inflammation. These effects likely depend on the individual:
-
A small study found no differences in acne after supplementing with whey protein isolate or maltodextrin placebo over 12 weeks.
-
Another small study had participants drink whey protein or glucose powder for 13 days. There were no differences in acne or skin oil production between groups.
For most people, whey protein appears safe for skin health when consumed in normal amounts. But it could worsen acne in those with underlying dairy sensitivities.
Does Beef Protein Cause Acne?
There are currently no studies examining the direct impact of beef protein powder on acne. However, we can make some logical conclusions based on the available evidence:
-
Since dairy sensitivities are uncommon in adults, beef protein is unlikely to cause issues for most people.
-
Beef protein contains similar hormones to whey and milk, but in very small amounts. These hormones are unlikely to impact acne at supplemental doses.
-
Beef protein causes a slower insulin spike compared to whey and other fast-acting proteins. Therefore, it may be less likely to increase oil production.
-
People with known sensitivities to cow’s milk could experience increased breakouts from beef protein. But the majority of users tolerate it well.
Overall, there is no research showing beef protein worsens acne. Anecdotally, most users report no issues with skin health after taking beef protein powder. Of course, individual reactions vary.
Tips to Prevent Acne from Protein Powders
Here are some tips to help prevent potential breakouts if you are concerned about acne from protein powders:
-
Start slow: Introduce any new protein powder gradually instead of in large doses to assess its effects.
-
Avoid adding other acne-triggers: Limit sugar, processed carbs and inflammatory oils like vegetable oils.
-
Stay hydrated: Drink plenty of water daily to help flush out toxins. Dehydration may exacerbate acne.
-
Cleanse skin after workouts: Remove sweat, oils and dirt by cleansing your skin after exercise.
-
Use acne-friendly powders: Try non-dairy proteins like egg, pea or collagen if you suspect whey or beef protein worsens your acne.
-
See a dermatologist: Get professional advice if breakouts persist after diet and lifestyle changes. You may need prescription acne treatment.
The Bottom Line
Based on the current evidence, beef protein is unlikely to cause acne in most people. There are no studies showing negative effects on skin health from beef protein supplementation.
However, individuals with underlying milk allergies or hormonal imbalances may experience increased breakouts from cow’s milk-based proteins. As with any diet change, pay attention to your body’s response.
For optimal skin health, focus on an overall balanced diet with plenty of fresh fruits, vegetables, healthy fats and lean proteins. Stay hydrated and practice a proper skincare routine. With some trial and error, you can enjoy dairy or beef proteins as part of an acne-free lifestyle.
Cases of whey protein acne described in medical journals
Here are some examples of whey protein acne that have been reported in the medical literature:
- For 30 days, whey protein supplements were given to 30 men who went to the gym often and had used protein calorie supplements before. Findings from the study showed that after 30 days, these men had significantly more acne pustules, papules, and comedones.
- Six men between the ages of 16 and 18 got acne after taking bodybuilding supplements with whey protein. Their skin condition drastically improved immediately after stopping the supplements.
- Five male bodybuilders who were adults had terrible acne breakouts after taking whey protein supplements.
- Five teenagers developed acne following whey protein supplementation. Most of these patients’ skin cleared after stopping the supplements. One redeveloped acne after starting the supplement again.
A few cases of vitamins B6 and B12 causing acne
- An article talks about a woman who had pustules and papules that were red and swollen, as well as swelling and redness on her face. Her inflammation decreased after stopping the supplement.
- A female patient got a papulopustular rash on her face, back, and chest about 12 hours after getting vitamin B12 injections into her muscles.
- In five women who took high doses of vitamin B12, acne-like breakouts happened afterward.
- After getting a vitamin B12 injection into her muscle, a 44-year-old woman showed up with bumps and sores on her face and neck.
Whey Protein Causes Acne | What the Fitness | Biolayne
FAQ
Does beef cause acne?
Does meat protein cause acne?
Does eating protein cause acne?
Can certain foods cause acne?
Research suggests that certain foods may contribute to acne. This could be due to their effects on inflammation or specific hormones that affect the development of acne. Acne is a common skin condition that affects nearly 10% of the world’s population (1).
Can diet affect acne or cause pimples?
Acne is a skin condition, where bumps are formed on the face due to the clogging of hair follicles with excess oil. It is associated with diet. It is seen that a diet rich in carbohydrates, oily foods, snacks, bread, and chips has caused an increase in acne formation. Eating processed food items rich in fat and oil leads to the worsening of acne.
Can dairy based protein powder cause acne?
“Dairy-based protein powders, such as whey or casein, may trigger acne because the levels of the amino acid leucine are higher in meat and/or dairy-containing diets compared to vegetarian and vegan diets,” Sepel explains. Leucine activates a growth regulator, possibly aggravating inflammation involved in acne.
Do Western diets cause acne?
A number of studies suggest that modern Western diets may increase the likelihood of acne, potentially due to the amount of high GI foods they often contain. GI is a way of measuring how quickly foods increase blood sugar levels in the body. Modern Western diets often contain high GI foods that have a significant effect on blood sugar levels.